midicnTheory 中文

Chromatic harmony is not "using accidentals". It is accidentals becoming the ordinary material of harmony — moving from decoration to structure.

Diatonic harmonyChromatic harmony
Status of accidentalsexception, decorationstandard material
Source of chordsthirds stacked within the scaleborrowed, reinterpreted, piled up from outside it
Centrestable and clearconstantly pulled about

Why it is so corrosive

This is the part worth grasping, and it reduces to one sentence:

Any of the twelve semitones can be read as "some key's leading tone".

So every semitone can mean "pointing somewhere". When they come thick and fast, the ear is pushed in one direction after another — the centre is not knocked down, it is pulled until it loses its balance.

That also explains where chromaticism historically ends: nobody abruptly abolished tonality; the centre simply could not hold once chromaticism was taken to its limit.

Four common devices

DeviceMethodEffect
secondary dominantgive a degree its own dominant (see [[concept:secondary-dominantsecondary dominant]])
chromatic passing chordinsert a chromatic connector between two chordssmooth but continuous drift
augmented sixtha chromatic chord containing an augmented sixth, which expands outward to an octavestrongly points at the dominant
enharmonic reinterpretationrespell a symmetrical structure such as a diminished seventh or augmented triad (see [[concept:enharmonicenharmonic]], [[concept:diminished-seventh

The fourth is the most destabilising: a symmetrical structure has no single root, so change the interpretation and you change the key.

It is not the same as atonality

One confusion worth clearing up: chromatic harmony can still be tonal. Wagner's Tristan is intensely chromatic, yet it still has centres and still resolves — just extremely delayed.

Chromatic harmonyAtonality
Is there a centre?yes, but stretched and postponeddeliberately abolished
Is dominant to tonic still used?yes, only by a longer routeno
Does harmonic function still work?yesno

In one line: chromaticism stretches tonality to its limit; atonality abandons it.

Diagram: the centre being pulled

The denser the accidentals, the more directions they point, and the less stable the centre diatonic early chromatic late chromatic atonal a clear centre, one direction begins pointing elsewhere many directions, the centre is stretched the centre is deliberately removed Key point: any of the twelve semitones can serve as one key's leading tone, so every one of them points somewhere

Listen: the pull of chromaticism

Hear a fully diatonic progression first (a firm centre), then imagine the same functional skeleton with several secondary dominants and chromatic passing chords inserted. The difference is not "a few extra notes" but that your ear stops being able to predict where the next arrival will be.

Common misconceptions

Listen in the library

Danse Macabre, S.555C110:20Liszt's transcription of Danse macabre — chromatic harmony runs throughout, pulling the tonality aboutDetailsSuite bergamasque: III. Clair de luneC14:36Debussy's Clair de lune — chromatic harmony serves not as a route to a key but as colour in itselfDetailsSound Ye the Trumpet CallC10:35An organ hymn as a control — accidentals are rare and restrained in traditional writing, a sharp contrastDetails

All tracks from midicn-lib — inline badge is the license tier (C1 commercial / C2 non-commercial / C3 study only).

Sources

  • 半音化和声指变化音成为和声的常规材料(副属、半音经过和弦、增六和弦、等音重解等),属和声学通则
  • 半音化的累积与调性中心的弱化、最终走向无调性的历史线索,为音乐史通行记载

Used for fact-checking only; all prose is original.